There is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to treating depression. While some individuals experience significant relief with antidepressant medications, others may find little benefit or struggle with unwanted side effects. At MidValley Healthcare in Boise and Meridian, we recognize how overwhelming it can be to navigate the wide range of mental health treatment options. That’s why we offer both expert medication management and cutting-edge alternatives such as NeuroStar® Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) therapy. If you’re exploring whether TMS or medication might be the better fit for your needs, this guide is designed to help you understand the key differences and important factors to consider.
How Do TMS Therapy and AntiAdepressants Work Differently?
Both TMS therapy and antidepressants aim to relieve symptoms of depression by improving brain function, but they do so in very different ways.
Antidepressants such as SSRIs or SNRIs alter the balance of neurotransmitters like serotonin and norepinephrine in the brain. They are taken orally, typically daily, and can take several weeks to begin working. These medications circulate throughout the body, so they often cause systemic side effects.
NeuroStar® TMS therapy, by contrast, is a non-invasive procedure that uses focused magnetic pulses to stimulate underactive regions of the brain associated with mood regulation—specifically targeting the left prefrontal cortex. The treatment is administered through a specialized device positioned gently on the scalp, delivering precise stimulation without the need for anesthesia or systemic medication. Unlike antidepressants, which affect the entire body through chemical pathways, TMS works directly and locally in the brain, offering a targeted approach with minimal side effects.
Although medication is commonly the first step in treating depression, it doesn’t work for everyone. If you haven’t found the relief you need—or if you’re looking for a treatment that doesn’t involve medication—NeuroStar® TMS therapy may be an effective alternative worth considering.
.png)
What Are the Side Effects of TMS Compared to Medication?
When comparing treatment options, understanding potential side effects is crucial. Antidepressants often come with side effects such as:
- Weight gain or loss
- Sleep disturbances
- Sexual dysfunction
- Dry mouth
- Digestive issues
- Emotional blunting or numbness
Sometimes, these side effects can be significant enough to cause patients to stop taking the medication altogether.
TMS therapy, by contrast, is generally well-tolerated with minimal side effects. The most commonly reported sensation is mild to moderate scalp discomfort or a headache during the first few sessions—symptoms that typically diminish as treatment progresses. Unlike many antidepressant medications, TMS does not cause weight gain, sexual dysfunction, or cognitive side effects. Treatments are conducted while you're fully awake, with no need for restraints, sedation, or recovery time, allowing you to resume normal activities right after each session.
At MidValley Healthcare, patient comfort and safety are priorities. Our providers carefully monitor your progress and are available to adjust your treatment plan as needed to minimize any discomfort.
Who Is a Good Candidate for TMS Instead of Medication?
NeuroStar® TMS therapy is typically recommended for adults and adolescents aged 15 and older who are living with treatment-resistant depression—that is, when symptoms persist despite trying one or more antidepressant medications. This FDA-cleared therapy offers a non-invasive alternative for individuals who haven’t found relief through traditional treatments. By safely stimulating targeted areas of the brain involved in mood regulation, TMS provides a new path toward recovery without the systemic side effects of medication.
You may be a good candidate for TMS if:
- You’ve experienced unpleasant side effects from antidepressants
- You prefer a non-medication approach
- You have not achieved remission from depression despite trying traditional treatments
- You are looking for a targeted therapy that does not require daily dosing
- You are seeking long-term symptom relief with minimal ongoing maintenance
TMS can be especially beneficial for individuals with co-occurring conditions like anxiety or OCD, as it often helps regulate brain activity related to emotional processing and executive function. At MidValley Healthcare, we conduct a thorough evaluation to determine whether TMS is appropriate for your unique mental health history and goals.
.png)
Personalized Depression Treatment in Boise and Meridian
Choosing between TMS therapy and antidepressant medication is a profoundly personal decision, and there are many factors to consider. At MidValley Healthcare, our team works closely with each patient to explore options, including TMS, medication management, and therapy, to develop a comprehensive, evidence-based treatment plan. Our commitment is to help you find the most effective path to healing.
Contact us